• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Mr. Shoes Pizza

At Mr. Shoes Pizza, we embrace a passion for exceptional food and community. Nestled in Rochester, NY, our restaurant specializes in mouthwatering pizzas, fresh salads, and crispy chicken wings, all crafted with quality ingredients. Whether you prefer the hearty Meat Lover's Pizza or the light Veggie option, there's something for every palate, including vegan choices. Our welcoming atmosphere is perfect for families and groups, featuring accessible facilities and outdoor seating. With convenient delivery, takeout, and catering options, we ensure every meal is enjoyable. Join us for lunch, dinner, or late-night cravings at Mr. Shoes Pizza – where flavor meets friends!

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Mr. Shoes Pizza, a vibrant culinary gem located at 1687 Mt Hope Ave in Rochester, NY. This restaurant has rapidly become a local favorite, offering an enticing array of pizza, salads, and chicken wings that cater to every palate. Whether you prefer classic flavors or adventurous toppings, Mr. Shoes Pizza promises a slice of heaven for everyone.

  • Diverse Menu: Mr. Shoes Pizza boasts a versatile menu that includes unique options such as the Chicken Wing Pizza, Meat Lover's Pizza, and a delightful Five Cheese Pizza. Vegetarians will love the Veggie Pizza, while those seeking a sweet twist can indulge in the Hawaiian Pizza.
  • Sizes for Every Appetite: Catering to groups of all sizes, the pizzeria offers various sizes of pizza, from personal 9" pies to large 17" sheets, perfect for gatherings. Gluten-free options are also available, ensuring everyone can enjoy a bite.
  • Convenient Features: Mr. Shoes Pizza stands out not just for its food but also for its accommodating atmosphere. They offer delivery, takeout, and even reservations, making it easy for you to enjoy their delicious offerings on the go or in a cozy, private dining setting. Plus, the restaurant is fully wheelchair accessible, with dog-friendly outdoor seating—a perfect spot for a casual lunch or dinner.

The ambiance at Mr. Shoes Pizza is inviting and family-friendly, with a quiet atmosphere that’s ideal for a laid-back meal. Additionally, they are ASL proficient and provide closed captioning on TVs, making the dining experience inclusive for all. And let’s not overlook the fantastic options for late-night cravings, with the kitchen serving up pies well into the evening.

As a food reviewer, I was particularly impressed by the Goody Two Shoes Special and the Philly Steak Pizza. Each bite is a journey, boasting fresh ingredients and savory flavors that keep you wanting more. The crust is perfectly crisp, yet soft enough to fold—a classic New York style that pizza lovers will appreciate.

Overall, Mr. Shoes Pizza is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a welcoming community hub that brings people together over delicious food. Whether you're dining in or taking out, you can expect stellar service, tasty dishes, and an inviting atmosphere. Don’t forget to check out their catering options for your next event! Call them at (585) 442-1000 to place an order, or simply stop by for a slice. Your pizza experience awaits!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Mr. Shoes Pizza
mike d
mike d

This is probably the best pizza place in Rochester. Their breaded wing dinner is absolutely fantastic. The quality of this food is outstanding and the portions are plentiful. You should ask about the white Buffalo pizza.

Angela R
Angela R

The cheese steaks subs are very good. Staff is extremely friendly and willing to accommodate special requests. The pizza crust gets me its very, very good. Definitely worth checking out if you want real NY pizza and cheese steaks.

Raven Illustration
Raven Illustration

Losing my mind over this. Never in my life have I had a pizza this good and Id know, I used to work at a family ru pizza place that was crazy good. ...

salty yorkpeppermint
salty yorkpeppermint

I called an order for a calzone and a mushroom burger. The burger was fantastic and the calzone was cooked perfectly and so cheesy that when I pulled a piece out it stretched like a fine mozzarella stick would. I called in after making an ...

Matthew Andrychuk
Matthew Andrychuk

Fresh and hot on a Saturday night. Good flavor. Worth it!

John Tresohlavy
John Tresohlavy

Although there are tables for dining in, this is really more a take out place. No bathrooms inside but great food.

John Lose
John Lose

I believe that this is the last Mr. Shoes in Rochester. They know the secret to making a fantastic pizza. I would also recommend their marinated chicken bread bowl salads, extremely delicious and filling.

David
David

I Stopped in for a slice i got the buffalo chicken one. The owner Tim came up to take care of me and was super friendly and helpful. The slice was fantastic. I will definitely be coming here more often.